AI is the new shelf
Shoppers are moving to AI fast, and search and marketplaces both turned from organic to paid.
Shoppers used to meet products on a store shelf, then on a search results page, then in a marketplace listing. Now a growing number ask ChatGPT, Gemini or Google instead, and the answer names a handful of products and a handful of shops. We call that list the AI shelf.
The brands on that list get the sale. For any brand or retailer that sells physical products, we think that makes AI shopping a strategic priority, and the timing makes it urgent.
How fast shoppers are moving
Shopify reported that orders from shoppers sent to its stores by AI assistants grew nearly 13 times from the first quarter of 2025 to the first quarter of 2026. The base is still small. Shopify says organic search still sends its merchants more sessions than all the AI platforms it tracks combined.
Deloitte’s July 2026 survey covered 13,500 consumers aged 18 to 59 in 15 European countries, 1,000 of them in the Netherlands. In the Netherlands 55% had already used AI to shop at least once. Across Europe the figure was 56%.
A shift this fast leaves little time to prepare, and doing well in Google rankings and marketplace listings does not carry over to AI answers. Those lean on tests, best-of lists, reviews, YouTube and Reddit.
Few brands fit in an answer
An AI answer names only a few products. In our own study of Dutch fashion, one brand appears in at least half of the answers that name brands in 20 of the 50 categories we measured (see “Who owns the AI shelf”). Any other brand has to get into answers where that one is already named at least half the time.
The other 30 categories have no such brand yet. A brand that gets in early there can end up as the one others have to dislodge.
Organic first, paid later
Search and marketplaces both opened with organic reach. Early movers built a position cheaply, then the platform sold the space and the price of a position rose.
Search now has ads above the results, and marketplaces fill their result pages with sponsored listings. AI has started down the same path: on 18 August 2026 OpenAI announced ads in ChatGPT across 31 European countries, the Netherlands included. Ads are labelled as ads, so the recommendation itself is still earned, and a brand that is recommended now holds a position a competitor may later have to pay for.
What to do first
First find out where you stand. For each product category you sell, check which brands ChatGPT, Gemini and Google name when a shopper asks what to buy, and whether yours is one of them, product by product. Do it per market in the shopper’s own language, and repeat it, since the answers change.
Then find out why a competitor is picked and you are not. The cause sits in the product, the offer or what others say about it, which spreads the work across e-commerce, marketing, pricing, PR and retail, so someone has to own it.
Both are better done before the shelf fills up and before a place on it costs more.
Citerio AI helps with these steps. We measure how AI recommends your brand and products, work out why competitors are picked, agree actions with your teams and measure again to see what changed.
Sources
- Shopify, “AI search insights”, 11 May 2026: orders from shoppers sent to Shopify stores by AI assistants, Q1 2026 against Q1 2025.
- Deloitte, “The Human and the Agent: The state of Agentic Commerce in Europe”, 14 July 2026: online survey of 13,500 consumers aged 18 to 59 in 15 European countries, 1 to 31 May 2026.
- OpenAI, “ChatGPT Ads expands across Europe”, 18 August 2026.
- Citerio AI, Dutch fashion study: 300 product questions about 50 fashion categories, asked three times on each of ChatGPT, Gemini and Google AI Overviews on 27 October 2026.